The creepy handyman Trenton Ducati is working in the toilet when Ian Levin bursts in. While he is peeing in the stall, Trenton grabs the poor boy and takes him back to his hideout. Trenton tortures a tied stud before poking him with a giant cock in the guy's ass. Suddenly, Officer Jacon Durham bursts through the door to rescue Ian, but because of where he is, he loses consciousness. His worst fears come true when Officer Durham is trapped in the grip of the Dread Handyman. Jacob was beaten by a flogger and forced to swallow Trenton's hard cock. Candle wax is poured over the officer's entire body until his legs are tied and his ass is open wide. After a merciless fucking, the Creepy Handyman explodes the officer's face with cum and makes him suck every drop. Brock Avery trains in the gym before being overpowered by the Spooky Handyman Trenton Ducati. Brock finds himself strapped to a punching bag with his mouth band closed. The creepy handyman removes his tied hairpin and punches him in the torso. After the "69" is turned upside down, the Spooky Handyman rips out the whip and mercilessly punches Brock from front to back before dragging him into the bathroom. Trenton tortures the stallion before tilting it and punching a hole in the back. The creepy handyman covers Brock's face with cum before milking his aching cock. Jackson Fillmore changes into workout clothes, unaware of the Dread Handyman Trenton Ducati watching him. Trenton can't help himself and ties Jackson to the bench. He sucks on the boy's toes, hits him on the chest and makes Jackson suck on his cock. Having prepared Jackson's hole for fucking, Trenton straps him to the treadmill and fucks him hard. After the workout, Trenton gives Jackson a fuck at the end of the workout and covers his face with cum.