Devin is in love with his best friend Josh. Why wouldn't he be? Josh is as sexy as he is unavailable, a deadly combination. With his annual Halloween party on the horizon, Devin distracts himself from his ennui and focuses on the drama of his roommate Garrett, the boy brewer. Witches aren't the only evil ones on Halloween, and being bad is a lot of fun. By the end of the night, will Devin get a treat from Josh, or will he realize it's too hard to be sweet with your straight man?